Lawrence County Museum of History

Lawrence County Museum of History & Edward L. Hutton Research Library

Who Killed Sarah Schafer? 

An Oct. 28, 2011, reenactment tracing Schafer's footsteps on the night of the Jan. 22, 1904 murder.

Cast of Characters: 

Captain Alexander played by Larry King; 
Harry Behr played by Matt Miller; 
William Cook, who found Sarah's body, played by Greg Baker;  
Dr. J.B. Duncan played by Jim Buher; 
Joe Heitger, one of the accused, was played by Aaron Baker;
Mrs. Johnson played by Lisa French; 
Eva Love played by Jessica Stewart; 
Simpson Lowe played by Charlie Titche;
James McDonald played by Drew Stewart; 
Mrs. Addie Smith, played by Annette Taylor;
Eli Stephenson, deputy prosecutor, played by Lewis Maudlin

929 15th Street, Bedford, IN 47421  |  (812) 278-8575  | | Tues-Fri: 9-4, Sat: 9-3